Dining at The Pig & Whistle in Cartmel: Great Food, Warm Hospitality and a Proper Country Pub
I spend a great deal of time in the Lake District, particularly the South Lakes, and one place I find myself returning to time and again is the gorgeous village of Cartmel.
With its cobbled streets, historic buildings and magnificent medieval priory, Cartmel is every inch the picture-postcard English village. But beyond its undeniable good looks, this charming little corner of Cumbria packs a serious punch when it comes to food and drink.
Famous as the home of the original Cartmel Sticky Toffee Pudding, the village is something of a culinary destination in its own right. There’s a wonderful cheese shop, an artisan bakery, a brewery, a cocktail bar and a gorgeous little ice cream shop, not to mention two Michelin-starred restaurants that have firmly established Cartmel on the gastronomic map.
And then there are the pubs. Proper country pubs, the sort that come into their own at this time of year, with roaring log fires, welcoming atmospheres and menus celebrating the very best of seasonal British produce. For a village of its size, Cartmel really does spoil you for choice.
In short, it’s a food lover’s paradise, and somewhere I never tire of visiting.
One of the village’s familiar names is The Pig & Whistle, a pub that has experienced something of a chequered past, undergoing various changes and reinventions over the years. Today, however, it has been beautifully restored and reimagined as a quintessential English country pub with dining at its heart.
There’s something particularly appealing about a traditional village pub that understands what makes it special. Not somewhere trying desperately to reinvent the wheel, but somewhere that embraces its heritage, celebrates good food and offers the sort of warm, relaxed hospitality that makes you want to settle in for the afternoon.
And that is exactly the sort of experience I was hoping to find at The Pig & Whistle.
A Warm Welcome and a Menu Full of Temptation
We had booked a table for lunchtime on a chilly autumnal Saturday, and on arrival, it was lovely to see the pub already fairly busy, with a warm, welcoming atmosphere and a pleasant buzz of conversation. We were greeted with a smile and shown to our table, and with drinks ordered, I wasted no time getting stuck into the menu.
Now, I do love a good pub menu, particularly one that offers something a little more interesting than the usual suspects, and The Pig & Whistle certainly delivers on that front.
The menu is an eclectic mix of comforting pub classics, hearty seasonal dishes and more adventurous offerings, with a playful sense of humour running throughout. There are plenty of nods to traditional British pub food, but with some imaginative twists and a few international influences thrown in for good measure.
The small plates section is particularly tempting, featuring everything from crispy cauliflower popcorn with chimichurri, chilli, lime and garlic mayo (£8) to honey-fried three-cheese balls (£8), sticky pigs in blankets glazed with maple and sage (£9), and king prawns with chilli, spring onion and garlic butter (£9). There’s also smoked salmon with whipped goat’s cheese on toasted sourdough (£10), alongside chicken wings and tenders with a choice of punchy sauces.
For those with a more traditional appetite, the ‘P&W Classics’ section offers some proper comfort food. Think slow-braised beef and stout pie with gravy, creamy mash or skin-on fries and seasonal greens (£22), beer-battered haddock with chips, mushy peas and homemade tartare sauce (£18), and a slow-braised venison stew with winter vegetables and herb dumplings (£20).
There are also some rather indulgent choices, including a fillet iron steak with garlic and chilli butter king prawns, chimichurri and fries (£26), and pan-roasted duck breast with garlic potato fondant, seasonal greens and blackcurrant gravy (£26). Fish lovers are equally well catered for with pan-roasted sea bass served with crushed new potatoes, greens, chorizo and a chilli, lime and parsley sauce (£22).
Elsewhere, the aptly named ‘Bun Fight’ section offers a selection of generously dressed burgers, while ‘Plot Twist’ introduces dishes such as Bang Bang Theory, a crispy cauliflower popcorn and sticky rice salad with sesame, spring onions and bang bang sauce (£18), and Mac to the Future, a suitably indulgent macaroni cheese made with mature Cheddar, Brie and Parmesan, topped with crispy onions and a golden Parmesan crust (£17).
There’s even a ‘Piggin’ Out’ sharing platter for two (£58), featuring burgers, wings, loaded fries and plenty of extras, although I suspect you’d need to arrive with a fairly serious appetite to tackle that one.
And, of course, no proper pub menu would be complete without a tempting selection of puddings. Here you’ll find everything from warm brioche and date pudding with sticky toffee sauce to vanilla cheesecake with winter berry compote, apple and vanilla crème brûlée, and a rather decadent-sounding chocolate, brownie, biscuit and marshmallow creation called S’moreish.
What struck me most was the sheer variety. This isn’t a menu trying to be overly sophisticated or pretentious. It’s hearty, approachable pub food with a few surprises, generous helpings of personality and enough choice to make deciding what to order something of a challenge.
And with the weather outside doing its best to remind us that autumn had well and truly arrived, I was more than ready for something delicious and comforting.
A Delicious Start and a Little Food Envy
We decided to share a portion of chicken tenders to start, opting for the buffalo sauce with blue cheese and garlic dressing (£9), and what a good choice they turned out to be.
Arriving piled generously into a basket, the chicken tenders were coated in a beautifully crisp, golden crumb, smothered in a glossy, fiery orange buffalo sauce and finished with generous drizzles of creamy blue cheese dressing and a scattering of fresh herbs.
They were absolutely delicious. The chicken was tender and succulent beneath its crunchy coating, while the punchy buffalo sauce worked brilliantly with the rich, cooling blue cheese dressing. Messy, indulgent and packed with flavour, exactly the sort of food you want to tuck into with a cold drink in a cosy country pub.
The portion was surprisingly generous too, and I was rather glad we’d decided to share. At £9, I thought they represented excellent value for money, particularly given the size of the serving.
I must admit to experiencing a little food envy when the table next to us received their honey-fried three-cheese balls. Served with a hot honey drizzle, they looked absolutely delicious, all golden, crispy and gloriously indulgent. Definitely something I’ll be ordering on a return visit.
So far, The Pig & Whistle was off to a very promising start.
Hearty Pub Classics and Beautifully Cooked Sea Bass
For our main courses, we both gravitated towards the more traditional side of the menu. He opted for the slow-braised beef and stout pie (£22), while I chose the pan-roasted sea bass (£22), and both proved to be excellent choices.
The pie was quite a sight when it arrived. A magnificent, golden-brown creation with a deeply burnished pastry crust, sitting proudly in a generous pool of rich gravy, accompanied by seasonal greens and a bowl of chunky skin-on fries.
At first glance, the pastry looked as though it might be rather heavy, but appearances can be deceptive. It was actually beautifully light, with a crisp, flaky texture that gave way to the hearty beef filling beneath. The stout gravy added a lovely depth of flavour, making this exactly the sort of comforting, satisfying pub dish you crave on a chilly autumn afternoon. A proper pie, and a very good one at that.
My sea bass was equally impressive, arriving as two generous pieces of pan-roasted fish, served over crushed new potatoes and seasonal greens, with pieces of chorizo scattered throughout and a wonderfully aromatic chilli, lime and parsley sauce.
The fish was beautifully cooked, with delicate, moist flesh and deliciously golden skin. I particularly enjoyed the combination of flavours here. The chorizo brought a lovely smoky richness, while the citrus and chilli added a welcome freshness and gentle kick to the creamy sauce.
If I were being particularly critical, I would say the sauce was just a touch on the salty side, perhaps owing to the chorizo, but it was nevertheless absolutely delicious. In fact, it was the sauce that really brought the whole dish together, and I found myself happily mopping it up with the potatoes.
Both dishes were generously portioned, beautifully presented and, most importantly, full of flavour. There was nothing fussy or unnecessarily complicated about either plate, just good, satisfying cooking with enough attention to detail to elevate the food beyond your average pub lunch.
And at £22 each, I thought both main courses offered very reasonable value, particularly considering the quality and quantity of food on the plate.
Too Full for Pudding, But There’s Always Next Time
There was a tempting selection of desserts on offer too, including warm brioche and date pudding with sticky toffee sauce, vanilla cheesecake with winter berry compote, and a rather indulgent-sounding chocolate and marshmallow creation. However, by this point, we were both absolutely stuffed, and even my enthusiasm for pudding couldn’t compete with the amount of food we’d already enjoyed.
Perhaps next time I’ll forgo a starter and save room for something sweet, although I suspect that will be easier said than done. The small plates menu is particularly appealing, and having already spotted those gorgeous-looking cheese balls making their way to the neighbouring table, I have a feeling my good intentions might go straight out of the window.
Still, it’s always nice to leave a restaurant with a few things on the menu you’re already looking forward to trying on your next visit.
Friendly Service and a Warm Welcome for Four-Legged Guests
Before wrapping up, I must give a special mention to the service, which was friendly, attentive and professional throughout our visit. From the warm welcome on arrival to being offered further drinks and a proper check-back to make sure we were enjoying our food, all the little details were taken care of.
Having spent many years working in hospitality myself, I’m a stickler for these things. Good service isn’t about someone hovering over your table every five minutes, but about getting the balance right, being attentive without being intrusive and making guests feel genuinely welcome. I’m pleased to say The Pig & Whistle got it spot on.
Another big plus, and something I particularly appreciate about pubs in the Lake District, is that it’s dog-friendly. We had our little French bulldog puppy, Barbara, with us, and she was made just as welcome as we were. In fact, she proved to be quite the hit with the staff, although I suspect she’s getting rather used to being the centre of attention wherever she goes!
The Final Verdict: Would I Return to The Pig & Whistle?
For me, The Pig & Whistle ticks all the right boxes. It’s a lovely, welcoming country pub serving generous portions of genuinely delicious food, with a varied and interesting menu, reasonable prices and excellent service to match.
Cartmel certainly isn’t short of wonderful places to eat, and with so much competition in such a small village, a pub really does need to deliver. On this occasion, The Pig & Whistle absolutely did.
Would I return? Without hesitation.
There’s plenty more on that menu I’d like to work my way through, those honey-fried cheese balls are still calling my name, and I really must leave room for pudding next time.
A thoroughly enjoyable Saturday lunch, a warm welcome for both us and Barbara, and another very good reason to keep returning to one of my favourite villages in the South Lakes.
The Pig & Whistle gets a definite thumbs-up from me – if you get around to visiting, tell them i sent you.
Pig & Whistle – Aynsome Road, Cartmel, Grange Over Sands LA11 6PL
Email: info@pigandwhistlecartmel.com
Words – Joanne Brook-Smith