Five of the Best Baked Potato Toppings, From Classic Comforts to Creative Twists
When I think of a healthy lunch, an easy midweek meal or a proper British classic, the baked potato is always up there in my top five. Cheap, filling and endlessly adaptable, the humble jacket potato has long been a staple — but recently, it’s been enjoying a very visible comeback.
Across TikTok and Instagram, ‘cult’ baked potato vendors are racking up millions of views with creative toppings and over-the-top fillings. Even Wetherspoons has got in on the action, recently launching a gourmet jacket potato menu — a clear sign that the baked spud is officially having a moment.
Of course, we all have our favourites (and yes, cheese and beans will always reign supreme). But whether you fancy pushing the boat out or sticking firmly to tradition, the baked potato is far more versatile than it gets credit for.
Here are five creative baked potato toppings we love, followed by five classic fillings that never go out of style.
Five Creative Baked Potato Toppings We Love
Sour Cream & Caviar
Extravagant? Absolutely. Worth it? Also yes. Cool, tangy sour cream paired with salty caviar on a piping-hot baked potato is unexpectedly brilliant. It’s indulgent, dramatic and very Real Housewives — but still rooted in comfort food.
Whipped Feta, Roasted Red Peppers & Chilli Honey
A modern, TikTok-inspired topping that earns its hype. Salty whipped feta, sweet roasted red peppers and a drizzle of chilli honey create the perfect balance of creamy, sweet and spicy. Fresh, colourful and surprisingly light.
BBQ Pulled Mushrooms
Comfort food without the meat. Slow-cooked mushrooms in smoky barbecue sauce give you that rich, pulled texture that works beautifully with fluffy potato flesh. Finish with melted cheese, slaw or pickled cabbage for crunch.
Garlic Butter Prawns & Lemon Crème Fraîche
Juicy prawns cooked in garlic butter, spooned over a hot baked potato and finished with lemony crème fraîche, feel indulgent but not heavy. A simple upgrade that feels restaurant-worthy.
Goats’ Cheese, Caramelised Onions & Balsamic Glaze
A reliable crowd-pleaser. Tangy goats’ cheese melts into the potato, sweet caramelised onions add depth, and a drizzle of balsamic glaze brings it all together. Comforting, but just elevated enough.
If That’s Too Adventurous… Five Classic Baked Potato Toppings We’ll Always Love
Sometimes, you don’t want reinvention — you want reliability. These are the baked potato fillings that have stood the test of time for a reason.
Cheese & Beans
The undisputed classic. Butter, fluffy potato, melted cheddar and hot baked beans. Simple, nostalgic and unbeatable.
Tuna Mayo
A lunchtime staple. Creamy tuna mayonnaise with black pepper (and maybe a squeeze of lemon) is light, filling and endlessly dependable.
Butter & Mature Cheddar
No distractions here. Just plenty of butter soaking into the potato and sharp, mature cheddar on top. Proof that simplicity wins.
Prawn Cocktail
A retro favourite that still delivers. Cold-water prawns mixed with Marie Rose sauce work surprisingly well against a steaming-hot baked potato. Lettuce optional, but recommended.
Chilli Con Carne
Hearty and warming, chilli con carne turns a baked potato into a full meal. Add sour cream or grated cheese and you’re sorted.
From budget lunches to indulgent comfort food, the baked potato proves once again why it remains one of Britain’s most loved dishes. Whether you’re loading it with caviar or sticking firmly to cheese and beans, the humble spud continues to earn its place on our plates.
Joanne Brook-Smith is a writer and editor with two decades of publishing experience. She launched Crave Magazine during the Covid period to create a fresh, inspiring space for food, travel and lifestyle content.
Crave Magazine: your essential guide to the best in UK lifestyle, food and travel.